The Ivy Coach Daily

April 17, 2021

Winning the Waitlist Game

The college waitlist game, while stressful, can be quite fruitful if you attack the process right.

Was your child recently placed on the waitlist of a highly selective university? Maybe more than one waitlist? Are you anticipating your child will be placed on even more waitlists as we near the release of Ivy League decisions on April 6th? Are college waitlists all you can think about these days? If so, know that you’re not alone. Around this time every year, students who have been waiting for months for their dream colleges to render verdicts on their applications open their decisions only to learn the colleges have punted. But while many students feel dejected after being placed in waitlist limbo by multiple schools, we encourage these students to do happy dances. They weren’t denied admission. Many students were denied admission. Yet waitlisted students still have a genuine shot of earning admission and, in our experience, when students are waitlisted at multiple highly selective universities, if they play their cards right, they often earn admission to at least one of these schools.

College Waitlists Are En Vogue This Year

As Scott Jaschik reports for Insider Higher Ed in a piece entitled “Waiting Lists: What to Expect,” “The pandemic has led to a surge in applications at the most competitive colleges — public and private. The new applications include minority and low-income applicants who in the past felt unwelcome or who are attracted by the fact that many of these colleges were test optional for the first time. (Colleges that cater to these students struggled for applications.) Many of the top colleges also admitted large early-decision/early-action classes. The result of all of these changes is that predicting yield — the percentage of admitted applicants who enroll — is likely to be more difficult this year. And when colleges are worried about yield, they tend to rely more on waiting lists than they do normally. ’I predict that we will see more waiting list activity this year due to the uncertainty institutions are facing around yield,’ said Angel B. Pérez, CEO of the National Association for College Admission Counseling. ’With students applying to more schools, yet fewer unique applicants, enrollment officers are worried about whether or not students intend to enroll at their institutions. Students may apply to 15 schools, but in the end, they can only show up at one.’”

Why College Waitlists Are En Vogue

So, yes, many students are being waitlisted this year and we agree with the CEO of the National Association for College Admission Counseling, an organization to which we are a member: colleges are waitlisting more applicants because they knew in advance they wouldn’t be as effective at projecting their yield. And why? Because when admissions officers at our nation’s highly selective universities are forecasting whether or not an individual student will likely attend, a key determinant — among other factors like their specificity in Why College essays — is whether or not they physically visited the campus for a tour and information session. With campuses closed and students unable to visit, admissions officers had to make predictions without this key data point. Of course, whether a student participated in a virtual tour and information session was included but attending a school from one’s living room just doesn’t require as much energy as visiting in person. It’s not as effective a gauge of interest.

Waitlisted Applicants Must Maintain Hope and Attack

Yet when students receive notifications that they’ve been placed in limbo, many give up home. So too do many of their parents. It’s something we’ll never quite understand. And why? Because waitlisted students absolutely have a chance of earning admission. We think of it as they’re running a marathon that is the highly selective college admissions process and they’re nearing the 22nd or 23rd mile. And now they give up? It makes no sense. Instead, you’ve got to fight, fight, fight. You’ve got to prove to each school that has placed you in limbo that they are your first choice. So how do you prove it? You prove it by sending them a powerful Letter of Enthusiasm filled with specific after specific about how you’re going to contribute your singular hook to that institution. We know. We’re being vague. Hey, what can we say…we’re a business. And one of our family business’ most delicious recipes is our unique recipe for how to approach writing a compelling Letter of Enthusiasm. One comment parents and students often say after hearing our students’ unique letters goes, “That is not at all what I thought a Letter of Enthusiasm should be. But now I get it.” We like to think of the waitlist season as a war. Each school is a battle, one that can be won. When a school places a student in limbo, you send in a powerful letter. When the next school places a student in limbo, you send in your next powerful letter. And so on. Attack after attack. And, yes, it’s absolutely ok to let each school know it’s your first choice. They don’t — and can’t — share information. But the task before waitlisted applicants is not to tell each school it’s their first choice. It’s to show them.

If your child needs help crafting a powerful Letter of Enthusiasm to a school that placed them in waitlist limbo, fill out our free consultation form, indicate waitlist at the bottom, and we’ll be in touch in short order. And, while you’re here, read what we have to say about sitting and waiting during this process.

You are permitted to use (including the content of the Blog) for your personal, non-commercial use only. You must not copy, download, print, or otherwise distribute the content on our site without the prior written consent of Ivy Coach, Inc.


If you’re interested in Ivy Coach’s college counseling,
fill out our complimentary consultation form and we’ll be in touch.

Get Started