“The Washington Post” is the elite of the elite when it comes to print journalism. “The Washington Post” broke Watergate thanks to the efforts of its intrepid reporters, Woodward and Bernstein. “The Washington Post” boldly published the classified “Pentagon Papers” at great risk to the paper, exposing the Unites States’ controversial history in Vietnam. And while one of these things doesn’t belong between Watergate, the Vietnam War, and college admissions, we blog about college admissions every day so we’ve got a thing or two to say about their reporting on the subject yesterday. Our criticism specifically concerns a statement that the SAT and ACT essays are becoming essentially irrelevant in college admissions. It is a boldfaced untruth.
The SAT and ACT Essays Matter Even When Colleges Drop Requirement
In a piece yesterday in “The Washington Post” by esteemed higher education reporter Nick Anderson entitled “Pencils down: Major colleges stop requiring essay test for admission,” he writes, “The SAT and ACT essay tests began with fanfare in 2005, a bid to assess the writing chops of college-bound students under the pressure of a clock. Now, many colleges say time’s up for those exams. With a few notable exceptions, the consensus in higher education is that the tests are becoming an afterthought even though hundreds of thousands of high school students still take them every year as one of the grinding rituals on the road to college.”
And while Nick Anderson’s reporting on higher education is typically spot on, as our regular readers know well, the assertion that the SAT and ACT essays are becoming an afterthought is simply not correct. By eliminating the SAT or ACT essay requirement, highly selective colleges encourage more students to apply. The more students to apply in a given year, the lower that school’s admission rate will invariably be and the higher the school will be ranked in the all-important “US News & World Report” ranking. Colleges are incentivized to inspire more students to apply, to drop requirements. But just because a school drops a requirement, it would be a mistake to presume that school still doesn’t want to see the score. Yes, you read that right. Princeton may have dropped the SAT or ACT essay requirement. You don’t think a Princeton admissions officer would prefer to see a great SAT or ACT essay score over no score at all? Don’t kid yourself.
SAT and ACT Scores Matter Even More at Test-Optional Schools
We can even take this one step further. One may think that test-optional schools don’t care to see SAT or ACT test scores. That too would be nonsense. In fact, we’d argue that test-optional schools want to see test scores even more than test mandatory schools. And why? Because test scores are still components of a test-optional school’s “US News & World Report” ranking. The data pool for the scores just comes from a smaller pool of applicants. So the scores of the students who do choose to submit test results at test-optional schools end up mattering even more. Think big fish, small pond.
If you don’t submit an SAT or ACT essay score, it raises a red flag — even if the school doesn’t require an SAT or ACT essay score. No school requires AP tests. You don’t think highly selective colleges want to see AP test results? Don’t kid yourself.