The Ivy Coach Daily

January 12, 2022

A Rhodes Scholar No More

A UPenn graduate’s Rhodes Scholarship was recently revoked (photo credit: Bryan Y.W. Shin).

Oh no she didn’t! When University of Pennsylvania graduate Mackenzie Fierceton was named a Rhodes Scholar in November 2020, she was the pride of UPenn. In fact, she — a self-proclaimed first-generation college student, low-income, former foster child — was even praised by UPenn’s president in a community newsletter. Wrote UPenn President Amy Gutmann at the time, ““Mackenzie is so deserving of this prestigious opportunity…As a first-generation low-income student and a former foster youth, Mackenzie is passionate about championing young people and dedicating herself to a life of public service.” But what if Mackenzie was not a low-income student? What if she was not the first in her family to go to college? What if she was not in foster care? What if her story would all soon unravel?

As Jerry Oppenheimer and Isabel Vincent report for The New York Post in a salacious piece entitled “’Rhodes Scholar’ claimed she grew up poor and abused — then her story started to unravel,” “Categorizing herself as a first-generation, low-income student with a history of horrific abuse — who also earned nearly straight A’s and was student-body president in high school — Fierceton certainly fit the bill. She was admitted to Penn in 2015 to study political science, then began studying for a clinical master’s degree in social work in 2018. When Fierceton’s Rhodes scholarship was announced, the Philadelphia Inquirer profiled the academic star in November 2020, noting that she ’grew up poor, cycling through the rocky child welfare system [and] bounced from one foster home to the next.’ As Fierceton said in that story: ’I would trade [the Rhodes honor] to have been adopted and have a family.’ But after that Nov. 22, 2020, profile ran, an anonymous accuser sent an email to Penn and the Rhodes Trust, claiming Fierceton’s story was ’blatantly dishonest.’ The email reportedly alleged that Fierceton grew up in St. Louis, Mo., with her mother, an educated radiologist; that her family was upper-middle class; and that she had attended a fancy private high school and enjoyed such high-end hobbies as horseback riding.”

And boom goes the dynamite. The lesson? Don’t lie on your college application. You’re either a first-generation college student or you’re not. It’s not an opinion. If your mother is a radiologist, it means she not only attended college but also medical school. If you didn’t grow up in foster care, don’t say you did. Not only is it wrong, but it’s just not worth it. And do remember, a college offers a student admission on the basis of their honest application. Should the college subsequently learn that a student is not a first-generation college student when they said they were or didn’t grow up in foster care and wasn’t underprivileged, that college can revoke an acceptance or even a degree. Why do it? Why risk it? Be honest. In college admissions and in life.

Remember when the Yale football coach resigned back in 2012 because it came out that he lied about being a contender for the Rhodes Scholarship?

You are permitted to use (including the content of the Blog) for your personal, non-commercial use only. You must not copy, download, print, or otherwise distribute the content on our site without the prior written consent of Ivy Coach, Inc.


If you’re interested in Ivy Coach’s college counseling,
fill out our complimentary consultation form and we’ll be in touch.

Get Started