The Ivy Coach Daily

October 29, 2019

The Mistake of Not Applying Early

Early Advantage, Early Decision, Early Action
To not apply in the Early round is to waste the most valuable card in elite college admissions.

If you’re a high school senior who isn’t applying this Early Decision / Early Action round, you have made the biggest mistake in the college admissions process. That’s right. We said it. You see, you’ll hear others tell you that it doesn’t matter when you apply, to take your time, to apply when you feel it’s right, and lots of other nonsense. But they’re not telling you the cold hard truth: it does matter when you apply as there is a major advantage in applying Early. Indeed the numbers tell the story.

The Statistical Advantage of Applying Early vs. Regular

For the Class of 2023, 5.2% of Regular Decision applicants earned admission to Brown. In the Early Decision round, 18.2% of applicants earned admission. At Dartmouth, it was much the same story: 6.1% of Regular Decision applicants earned admission, while 23.2% of Early Decision applicants got in. At UPenn, 5.5% of Regular Decision applicants earned admission, while 18% of ED applicants got in. At Harvard, 2.8% of Regular Decision applicants earned slots, while 13.4% of Early Action applicants got in. Shall we go on or are our readers getting the idea? The trend holds true at each and every one of the Ancient Eight institutions.

The Nonsensical Argument Against Applying Early

And so why don’t all students apply in the Early round? Well, some students come from high schools at which the high school counseling isn’t all that good. The students aren’t receiving sound advice. Still others are led to believe by folks like New York Times columnist Frank Bruni that the Early round is essentially a playground for the privileged and if you’re not privileged, you need not apply Early. And that, in our humble opinion, is a load of apple pie, dental floss, and yesterday’s coffee grinds all mixed together in one.

The Argument the Early Round is Filled with Recruited Athletes and Legacies

“But, Ivy Coach, isn’t the Early round filled with recruited athletes?” Yes! “And, Ivy Coach, isn’t the Early round filled with legacies and development cases?” Yes! “So why are you encouraging me to apply Early? Aren’t the statistics not painting an accurate portrait? Isn’t it all somewhat deceiving” No! The statistics are absolutely painting an accurate portrait. It’s easier to get in during the Early round than the Regular round by a wide margin. This is true at each and every highly selective college.

It Would Logically Then Follow the Regular Round is Filled with Underrepresented Minorities and Low-Income Students

In fact, let’s ask some questions back at you so you realize your error. “Isn’t the Regular round filled with low-income students? Isn’t the Regular round filled with underrepresented minorities? Isn’t the Regular round filled with students who will be the first in their families to attend college? Aren’t these all coveted groups by highly selective colleges?” You bet! So how exactly does the logic of Frank Bruni make sense? Why shouldn’t any student who wants an advantage in the highly selective college admissions process — irrespective of their race, irrespective of their socio-economic status, etc. — apply by November 1st?

And don’t tell us that you want to weigh financial aid offers. That’s more dental floss mixed with coffee grinds and apple pie. Plug your numbers into the Net Price Calculator online and you can see precisely what kind of aid you might qualify for. Or you’ll realize you don’t qualify for aid at all. In our experience, the folks who wonder if they qualify for aid…don’t qualify.

You are permitted to use (including the content of the Blog) for your personal, non-commercial use only. You must not copy, download, print, or otherwise distribute the content on our site without the prior written consent of Ivy Coach, Inc.


If you’re interested in Ivy Coach’s college counseling,
fill out our complimentary consultation form and we’ll be in touch.

Get Started