Are younger siblings at an advantage when they apply to a highly selective college that their older sibling attends or attended in the past? Yes, with one important caveat. They must apply in the Early Decision or Early Action round — not in the Regular Decision round. At most highly selective colleges, if these younger siblings choose not to apply Early to the institution that their older sibling attends or attended, they will lose those sibling bonus points in admissions. And this all brings us to an editorial written by a current Brown student, Mark Liang, in which he powerfully articulates on the pages of “The Brown Daily Herald” why Brown should admit his younger sister. It’s a terrific editorial that hangs a lantern on some of the inequities in the highly selective college admissions process and it’s one that not so subtly speaks to the advantage of family connections to a university.
A Plea from a Brown Student to Brown Admissions
Liang writes in his piece for “The Brown Daily Herald” entitled “Let my sister into Brown,” “I didn’t apply early decision, but I nevertheless have a modest proposal for the Admission Office: Please, pretty please, let my sister — Joyce Shao-Wei Liang, Aries, would-be Sagittarius and current high school senior — into Brown. Why? Just because. After all, since when does Brown need clear reasons to make their admission decisions? Sure, there are many non-academic intangibles that could affect her acceptance — but then again, Brown has always made it clear that those intangibles are not major factors in admissions, so why should we even worry?”
And from there, he gets pithy. There’s this zinger: “I mean, it’s not like Brown ever considers legacy status, sibling or otherwise. Nepotism absolutely does not exist in any form within the hallowed halls of this university!” And this one: “And we know that my sister’s decision to apply to Brown early won’t matter at all, because when has early decision ever affected people’s chances? The Admission Office’s website clearly states, ‘The Board of Admission makes the same decisions under Early Decision that it would under the Regular Decision plan.'” Or this one: “And it’s not like the college-admissions game is money-driven in any way. Money is a social construct and has no role to play in any decision made by this university.”
An Ill-Advised Editorial on the Admission of a Sibling
No doubt, Liang’s editorial is the finest editorial we’ve read in a college newspaper in 2017. And, as our readers know well, we read a whole lot of editorials on the college admissions process. His writing is pointed, acerbic, and the piece is not only well crafted but it also happens to all be true. Of course, like at every highly selective institution, there is nepotism at Brown. Of course legacy status matters. Of course Early Decision candidates to Brown are at a distinct advantage over Regular Decision candidates. Of course money is a factor in admissions decisions — colleges are not truly need-blind.
But why did Liang write this editorial now in Brown’s student newspaper? Why here, why now? As he shares, his sister is currently up for admission in the Early Decision round at Brown. Calling admissions officers out on the hypocrisy of the entire process won’t serve his sister’s case for admission. We sure do hope this piece doesn’t hurt his sister’s case for admission because if his sister is anything like her brother, she’s sharp, fun, and insightful — she’d be everything Brown should be looking for in applicants. And yet if his sister, Joyce Shao-Wei Liang, were our student at Ivy Coach, we’d have never allowed her older brother to write this piece. No way. We’d have censored him. Hopefully, for Mark’s sister’s sake, the Brown admissions office is extremely self-aware and self-deprecating.
Have a question on the admission of younger siblings? Let us know your question by posting it below. We look forward to hearing from you!
You are permitted to use www.ivycoach.com (including the content of the Blog) for your personal, non-commercial use only. You must not copy, download, print, or otherwise distribute the content on our site without the prior written consent of The Ivy Coach, Inc.